Wednesday, March 23, 2016

Vaccine conspiracies: Bahh. yet

I have worked in poor areas of the USA and overseas, and I tear my hair out when I see upper middle class celbrities etc. decry vaccines and have their stuff picked up by conspiracy sites, by "major" newspapers who report the controvery, and then by ignorant Mullahs (or sometimes bishops) who persuade people to avoid vaccines.

Attention: Measles kills. Whooping cough Kills. Polio cripples. Tetanus kills.

I've seen these things, and not just in the USA.

A lot of this is people needing a scapegoat for their child's autism etc. I always wonder how there are huge outcries against vaccines when much of the "epidemic" seems to be a change in the diagnostic criteria (and also that kids who 40 years ago would have been labled "retarded" and put into institutions, and parents went on to have more kids, and were assured the child was better off with "experts".

But now they are left at home for their parents to try to cope... in a society where extended families are non existant and where financially both parents are forced to work to keep in a middle class lifestyle...bearing the high cost of medical care, the loss of money from a job, and the inability to care for the other kids in the family...often parents divorce since often the stress of the child means that parents fight, blame each other subconsciously, and divorce).

So modern"bioethicists" insist it is better for the parents and the family just to kill the kids to avoid these terrible problems.

Ah, but another way to cope is to blame someone else.

I just read The Litigators, (audiobook link here) about a class action lawsuit and the legal shennaingans around it. It was probably fake (some problems but not the death pill claimed by the lawyers)...

but a subplot was about a child left brain damaged from lead in a toy. A toy manufactured in China. A toy subcontracted by an ethical firm that didn't know some corrupt manufacterer in China was cutting cost by using lead paint on a toy. In the book, the toy manufacter took responsibility and gave a huge settlement without fighting.

So was this based on reality?

2011 article in the NYDN:

Toxic lead replaced by even more toxic cadmium in children's toys, trinkets

Now that lead has been banned from children’s products, some Chinese manufacturers have been substituting the even more dangerous heavy metal cadmium, especially in costume jewelry, an Associated Press investigation reveals.
Cadmium is a known carcinogen that, like lead, can delay brain development in young children, leading to learning disabilities. Research also shows that long-term exposure can cause cancer and kidney problems.
but there were no cadmium standards in 2011 so Walmart pled they followed the letter of the law in selling such things.

In a written statement, Wal-Mart insists that it makes safety a priority. "We consistently seek to sell only those products that meet safety and regulatory standards," Wal-Mart states. "Currently there is no required cadmium standard for children's jewelry."
so is this still true in 2016?

This 2015 article from the Environmental working group webpage  notes the law hasn't been updated since 1976, and has denied consumer petitions to update standards in testing cadmium in toys and children's jewelry.

The dirty little secret is that it is not only big business avoiding regulations, but that much of the US manufacturing is now done overseas, where there is less oversite, and in places like China (and to a lesser extent India) where you can get away with it if you bribe the right people or if the regulator is a family member.

NaturalNews article 2013 about "organic food" from China...even if the farmers follow the law ..that irrigates using contaminated water.

we grow organic brown rice.

The bad news: brown rice concentrates some heavy metals. NYT article here.

most are small and not dangerous. Polished rice is healthier this way but has lost it's fiber and B vitamins.

Arsenic can come from ground water (especially deep wells: The use of clean deep well water in Bengladesh has cut deaths from dystentary but now they have an epidmic of arsenic).

But we are probably safe from pollution, being upstream from Manila...but what about all those newfangled mercury containing light bulbs thrown out carelessly here? or other toxins from the city dump upstream from our farm?


(note: Here we pretty well went broke following the law because we competed with rice growers who did use chemicals and pesticides when the regulator wasn't around.).

so anyway: Lack of environmental regulations not only hurt people but hurt those who try to follow the rules (how many US factories went under competing with substandard manufactured stuff from China? )

ah, but getting back to vaccine conspiracies:

Guess what: There is a major vaccine problem in China.

Via Weibo (the Chinese equivalent to twitter/facebook).

The Shandong State Food and Drug Administration is investigating the illegal distribution of vaccines, including those for hepatitis B and rabies, by nine different pharmaceutical companies. As authorities are checking where the vaccines have been sold, media are reporting they have been sold in a total of 24 different places, including municipalities and provinces all over China such as Beijing, Sichuan, Shandong, Shanxi, Hunan, Xinjiang etc.
This is original, researched content by What's on Weibo. You are free to link to this article. Please identify this website or author when you base content on this source or quote from it. Do not reproduce our content without permission – you can contact us at info@whatsonweibo.com, we’re happy to hear from you. Copyright (C) http://www.whatsonweibo.com. Read more at: http://www.whatsonweibo.com/vaccine-scandal-illegal/
a longer article on ChinaDaily:

A mother and daughter from Shandong province have allegedly sold vaccines worth 570 million yuan ($88 million) illegally since 2010 in China, posing severe health risks to users, police said on Friday.
It is believed to be the largest case of its kind in China in terms of the amount of money involved, according to media reports.
The police in Jinan, the provincial capital, confirmed an earlier report by the Paper, a Chinese news organization based in Shanghai, that the two suspects allegedly sold vaccines that were not properly refrigerated, as required by national standards, in 18 provinces and regions across the country.
and here is the kicker:

The fact that they are suspected of doing it for so long exposes flaws in the supervision system of the country’s vaccine industry, he said.
ya think?

ah, but the WHO lauds the entrance of China in to the world vaccine marketplace  (2014)at the same time that "counterfeit" and substandard drugs (mainly from China and India) are killing millions.

the article notes that it is not just manufacturing that has to be careful: You also have to store and ship the vaccines so they don't get hot and lose their ability to work.

and for those following the paper trail of donations to the CLinton foundation being used to get influence with the US Gov't, this is nor comforting:

The Clinton Health Access Initiative (CHAI) has been working with Chinese suppliers to support their applications for WHO prequalification for several vaccine candidates for the last two years, says Joshua Chu, CHAI’s Director, Vaccines Markets.The initiative also works with donors and other agencies to implement innovative market-based mechanisms, such as long-term volume guarantees, to make donor funds go further when purchasing vaccines. So far it has established volume guarantees with vaccine manufacturers in India and with other developing countries for other health products.
then there is this "Whoops":CZ magazine article that mentions the heptatis vaccine deaths.

and laments the meme: But they will be cheap! We Need Cheap!

So the conspiracy vaccine conspiracies will notice:

not just the mullahs or bishops but those in the USA:

this vaccine scandal was carelessness in storing and shipping.

But what about carelessness in manufacturing?

Or outright fraud, as in the heparin or melamine baby milk scandals, where regulation was in place and being done correctly, but the manufacturer figured out a cheaper way to make the stuff that woudn't be detected by ordinary regulatory testing.

Sigh.
-------------

Shanghai daily reports: China is going to fix the loopholes that let these ladies in business.

Lots of other suspects involved.





Sunday, February 21, 2016

Hansen's disease in ShagriLa

AlJazeerah has a nice article about Nepal's busy Leprosy hospital.

Despite the very low risk of infection, the stigma surrounding the disease can be extreme in Nepal. Patients are often isolated and abandoned by their families and communities in a country where the law prohibits infected people from working or marrying. In some rural areas, the disease is considered a curse from God as a punishment for sins committed in a former life.
a similar stigma is found in India, and was present in Europe and in the Bible.

Why? It is not very infectious, but it spreads quickly to children by skin to skin contact, and it leads to deformities that are ugly.

the clinic was founded by a British nurse, but the head doctor now is a local whose parents had the disease and he was raised in a lepersarium.

the disease is easily treated as an outpatient in places like Africa, where the stigma is less, but there is a need for inpatient treatment due to comorbidity (secondary infections of their wounds of example) and need to insure folks take their medicine (similar reason for TB hospitals). They also need specialized rehab work for their injuries and medical problems.

I say only one (mild) case in Zimbabwe, where outpatient treatment wiped it out, but there were still imported cases from Mozambique.

But there might be another reason for isolation.
Sister Humberta, one of our older nurses, had worked in one sanitarium. Once, when I had a patient with ulcers etc. and I asked her opinion if it was Hansen's disease, and she said no: It didn't stink like Leprosy. (it turned out to be ulcerated Kaposi's sarcoma, probably from HIV, which back then was not yet known about).

And in Liberia, I knew the doctor who ran the Hanson disease outreach. She had gone into easier work after the stress of working as a surgeon through the Nigerian civil war, and gotten her PhD in public health. Her job was to go to villages and find cases and put them on treatment, and then check them every three months or so that they were taking the medicines etc.

The outreach was funded by the Knights of Malta, a group beloved by conspiracy theorists.

The truth is more mundane: They are an "independent country" (which is now a mansion in Rome) and they issue their own passports.  UKIndependent article about that group.

. The 118,500 members, employees and volunteers are now in the charity business, working or supporting aid projects in some 120 countries on an annual operating budget of more than £150million.
Haiti, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and most recently the Philippines, have all been recipients of its emergency relief. Most recently, it even started projects in Turkey, many of which support Syrian refugees, meaning that the eight-pointed Maltese Cross has returned to the modern incarnation of its old enemy.

y es, but conspiracy theories are more fun!

Friday, February 19, 2016

for later reading (blame colombus?)

an article on syphillis.

I'm too fuzzy minded to read it now, but the historical tracing of the epidemic from Columbus' sailors to Italy to the soldiers of Charles via the lovely Napolian ladies is pretty clear.

True, there may have been isolated cases before then, but given the promiscuity of the medieval days one does wonder why no one noticed it.

On the other hand, syphillis is related to yaws, which used to be common in Africa and spread by ordinanry skin contact. No, I've never seen a case. But early syphillis was a lot more virulent in the first hundred or so years it was in Europe, and could be spread by fairly innocuous ways like kissing (not deep kissing, but the cheek to cheek contact common those days when one greeted another, presumably via saliva containing germs and open skin...a few cases of HIV have been spread this way).

So is it new or old or just mutated?

More recently, Zuckerman was also part of a team that published a 2011 paper in the Yearbook of Physical Anthropology reviewing 54 different reports of treponemal disease in pre-Columbian Europe. None of the cases, they argued, presented evidence strong enough—either in the dating of the bodies or the signs of syphilis they displayed— to validate the pre-Columbian hypothesis.



and remember: They have found female DNA in a few people in Norway.

And of course, the cod fishermen would fish off the coast of Canada, so presumably could have visited the lovely ladies there.

Or did the Mali navy who got blown off course to Brazil catch it and bring it to Africa, or maybe they took yaws to Brazil? Remember, the "pristine rain forest" of the Amazon was very populated in those days with millions of farmers.

finally, even a rare case in China or Japan might have managed to get there via polynesians or just sailors who got blown off course.

The presence of African sweet potatoes in Polynesia sugggests that there were some contacts.


Saturday, February 13, 2016

Neanderthal DNA linked disease?

I only have a link to a summary, but this article claims that Neanderthal DNA is associated with a lot of diseases.

NASHVILLE, TENNESSEE—Researchers from Vanderbilt University used a database of 28,000 anonymous individuals, whose DNA samples were linked to their electronic health records, to look for Neanderthal DNA variants and see if they could be connected to modern health problems. “Our main finding is that Neanderthal DNA does influence clinical traits in modern humans: We discovered associations between Neanderthal DNA and a wide range of traits, including immunological, dermatological, neurological, psychiatric, and reproductive diseases,” evolutionary geneticist John Capra said in a press release

Problem number one:

Association does not mean causation.
It could be coincidence. And unless one proves the Neanderthal DNA was in the part of the genome that was associated with the disease, the question of coincidence is likely.
one example can be found in the newspaper article stating that Neanderthals were redheads, so that would explain why some Europeans had red hair. A closer examination showed that the genes were different.

Problem two: Neanderthal DNA varies by race.

it is higher in East Asians than Europeans, but is almost non existent in Africans

didn't Vanderbilt have DNA from African Americans?
Depression and addiction and autoimmune disease are present in African Americans too.

But then I see: "Actinic keratoses" (pre skin cancer lesions). Uh, this merely means someone is pale and goes out in the sun a lot. Again a racial trait due to melatonin (and yes, African albinos get skin cancer too). So do neanderthal genes increase the risk, or is it higher in whites, and white Europeans have more Neanderthal genes? (skin color seems to be paler in northern climates, e.g. Korea...think VitaminD deficiency and ricketts..the exception is those who eat fatty fish like salmon...e.g. Eskimos...think cod liver oil).

The immune problem seems to be identified with the location of the gene in other studies, but the rest of these sound like junk science.

UKMail article. suggests the "interbreeding" stuff might be more complicated than earlier articles suggest.

but what is not clear when they say "x percent" of humans have neanderthal genes, if they mean X percent of the population, or if 100 percent of folks have x percent of the Neanderthal dna.

from Natgeo

Everyone living outside of Africa today has a small amount of Neanderthal in them, carried as a living relic of these ancient encounters. A team of scientists comparing the full genomes of the two species concluded that most Europeans and Asians have between 1 to 4 percent Neanderthal DNA. Indigenous sub-Saharan Africans have no Neanderthal DNA because their ancestors did not migrate through Eurasia.

so back to the original article: Did they actually check out the gene or not?

 For example, a Neanderthal variant that increases blood coagulation may have sealed wounds more quickly and prevented infections. 
John Hawks article on DNA in populations.
Wonder what the percentages would show for Mongolians/Koreans/Native Americans, who were from Siberia, not Han Chinese.

guess I'll have to do a bit more study into this area, because right now I'm confused at what is being claimed.

Thursday, January 28, 2016

Veteran suicide: Parsing the numbers

lots of veteran suicides, but most of them are VietNam vets, not from Iraq/Afghanistan.


press release from VA here;

with links to the longer (59 page) report for later reading.

I am not sure what the shorter article meant when referring to 22...the suicide rate is 22 for normal people, but in actuality the number is 13 for women and higher in men.

But for female physicians and for some veterans it is much higher...I don't have the data in front of me, but I seem to remember an "ain't it awful" report smearing all vets as psychos who pointed out a 29 suicide rate in veterans was proof, and then I googled that the suicide rate for female physicians was 29.

At least the VA does prevention...the NEJM, if I remember correctly, suggested a similar intervention for high risk physicians (e.g. women physicians and psychiatrists).

Of course, the NEJM also pushes suicide as a social policy, so they tend to be hypocrites.






headsup TeaAtTrianon

Wednesday, January 27, 2016

Zika virus ahead

Lots of kerfufle about the Zika virus.

The LATimes says the WHO predicts it will hit the USA, but actually it already has.
Although the virus popped up in Africa during the 1950s, and later in the Pacific Islands, including Micronesia, it had not been seen in the Americas until it appeared in Brazil in May. It unclear how it got there. One theory is that the virus entered the country during or around the 2014 World Cup, when hundreds of thousands of people were visiting from around the globe. Weather conditions may be contributing to its spread, some experts have suggested. "Maybe El Niño has something to do with the rapid spread, although we aren't sure," said Dr. Peter Hotez, dean of the National School of Tropical Medicine at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston. The lack of any previous exposure has also increased vulnerability because the populations lack immunity

uh, Weather (i.e. "global warming" or "el nino" only increases or decreases rain. The mosquitos live there all the time).

the bad news?

  • The symptoms of Zika are similar to those of dengue and chikungunya, diseases spread through the same mosquitoes that transmit Zika.

which are:


  • The most common symptoms of Zika are fever, rash, joint pain, or conjunctivitis (red eyes). Other common symptoms include muscle pain and headache. The incubation period (the time from exposure to symptoms) for Zika virus disease is not known, but is likely to be a few days to a week.
  • The illness is usually mild with symptoms lasting for several days to a week.

 the main danger is a birth defect, microcephaly which is devestating to the child.

Me, I will be sarcastic: Right now, the CDC wants to screen women and babies for it, but there is no treatment.

Ah, but expect an upsurge in late term abortions and arguments for "infanticide" in the press in the near future.

Tuesday, January 26, 2016

why are younger folks getting colon cancer?

Article HERE.

when I started medical school, most colon cancer was in the rectum, so we had to do rectal examinations on all our patients, since over half the cancers were withing finger lengthe of the anus. We family docs also learned how to do simple sigmoidoscopies, using the hard tube type (later, the flexible one was used, but by that time, we had enough specialists so I stopped doing them).

To cure them, they removed the rectum and diverted the colon to drain into a colostomy bag...and we had lots of discussions if they could later join or divert the feces to the anus, which had a sphincter, for social reasons.

But as time went on, these cancers became more rare (I hadn't seen one in the last 10 yrs of medicine). But colon cancer upstream increase so the emphasis was to do colonoscopies.

This is a more invasive procedure, often requiring some anesthesia, and an expensive scope and lots of training to do it well.

So how should we screen? Well, if you do "occult blood" screenings, often folks never bring them back, and there is a high false positive and false negative rate.

We did see colon cancer in young people: we had a family where one aunt died at age 34, and although funds for the IHS were limited, we tried to get the family screened...we even had a 7 year old sent out for a pediatric colonoscopy at a specialized center (she had pre cancerous polyps removed)...

So why are there more colon cancer? Or is it just that older folks are picked up and their pre cancerous polyps removed before they turn into cancer?

And is the changing history due to diet? Burkett noted that colon cancer was rare in east Africa, where high fiber corn sadza was the main food. So yes, fiber probably helps, by increasing transit time i.e. getting rid of toxins (yes, this sounds like those colon cleansing fads, but there is a small bit of truth in them: They merely exaggerate to make money).

Meat may increase the rate, or maybe it just means if you eat meat, you get less fiber in your diet.

Ironically, aspirin and Ibuprofen cut the rate of colon cancer.

In the meanwhile, stomach cancer, which was almost an epidemic at the turn of the 20th century, pretty well disappeared as smoked food was replaced with chemicals to keep them from rotting.
Nowadays, if you get a stomach cancer, it is probably lymphoma (something almost unheard of when I was in medical school...and again, I have had two patients with stomach lymphoma in my last ten years of practice but no cancer of the stomach for the last 20 years of practice)

something I will have to search google about.