Friday, January 8, 2016

It's done with mirrors

 Another article (on Gizmodo this time) about how "experts" are saying that cancer screening doesn't save lives.


For example, a 30 year follow-up to a colon cancer study showed that for every 10,000 patients who were screened for colon cancer, 128 died of the disease, while the rate of death due to colon cancer was 192 out of every 10,000.
 Those numbers indicate that screening is critical. It causes mortality due to colon cancer to plummet.
But another set of numbers is less encouraging. Of the group of unscreened patients, 7111 out of 10,000 had died by the time of the follow-up. Of the screened group 7109 had died—making for a difference of two people.

the article then goes on to blame the "stress" of treatment, the "stress" of false positive results.

Ah, but the dirty little secret is: These people are often older and have comorbidities (lots of things wrong with them)

So they die of something else.

When the anti cholesterol medicines came out, a similar finding was found: If you take it, your heart attack rate is slightly lower, but the death rate was the same.

In one study, the reason for the difference was death by violence/accident/suicide/homicide.

Another study was done, and the death rate was the same due to cancer of the colon deaths.

The Docs joked that since they'd rather die of a heart attack than cancer, why take the medicine?

Similar problem here.

Another dirty little secret is that the numbers sound impressive, but they are low risks for the actual patient.

then there is the "GIGO" problem: garbage in, garbage out.

What’s more, the researchers did a review of 10 meta-analyses of cancer screening studies. These meta-analyses combined the results from several studies to give an overall picture of the research done on screening for different cancers. Only three showed a reduction in mortality due to specific cancers. Not one showed a reduction in overall mortality.
a lot of these studies include those where there are a lot of drop outs, or the population was not representative of normal folks. In others, the numbers weren't significant.

Finally, not mentioned: that many cancers metastasize early, when it is too small to detect from screening. So early diagnosis of a young women with aggressive hormone dependent breast cancer might not make a difference, since it has already spread.

This might not be true of an elderly  person with slow growing cancer, who will die of something else.

And finally a dirty little secret: Malpractice suits are one reason that doctors were forced to order a lot of tests that didn't make a difference.

I was once sued for not ordering a test that wasn't being done because it was being done experimentally 500 miles away, the lawyer argueing that I should have known that the test was available.

Ironically, what saved me in that malpractice suit was sex: The lawyer was caught sleeping with the 16 year old daughter of one of his "expert" witnesses, and the sister of the deceased who knew her sister didn't keep follow up appointments, knew that the husband suing for "wrongful death" had a bimbo on the side, which made his wife ignore the growing cancer as a way of passive suicide...

Thursday, January 7, 2016

Ancient ulcers

Scientist have found HPylori in the stomach of Otzi the iceman...

The scientists found a potentially virulent strain of bacteria, to which Ötzi's immune system had already reacted. "We showed the presence of marker proteins which we see today in patients infected with Helicobacter," said the microbiologist. A tenth of infected people develop further clinical complications, such as gastritis or stomach ulcers, mostly in old age. "Whether Ötzi suffered from stomach problems cannot be said with any degree of certainty," says Zink, "because his stomach tissue has not survived and it is in this tissue that such diseases can be discerned first. Nonetheless, the preconditions for such a disease did in fact exist in Ötzi."

Tuesday, January 5, 2016

Yes, and it was important

Improbable research usually links to papers about absurd reseach, but today's link is about the morbidity caused by diarrhea in soldiers serving in Iraq: probably because two of the four authors had absurd names. (Riddle and Tribble).

ah but it is a major problem... and they also link to another paper about the problem of constipation.

Well, some people attribute Napoleon's loss at Waterloo to his hemorrhoids (a complication of constipation).
or maybe not:
As detailed in Phil Mason’s book “Napoleon’s Hemorrhoids: And Other Small Events That Changed History,” some scholars believe the French military leader suffered a painful bout of hemorrhoids on the morning of the Battle of Waterloo that prevented him from riding his horse to survey the battlefield as was his custom and could have contributed to his defeat. However, Waterloo expert Alasdair White told the New York Times that the story is “an absolute myth” concocted by Napoleon boosters because they “cannot believe that the great man lost, so there must have been something wrong with him.”

social networks are important to health

Related to the previous post on suicide is a study that having a "social network" is important.

The more social ties people have at an early age, the better their health is at the beginnings and ends of their lives, according to a new study. The study is the first to definitively link social relationships with concrete measures of physical well-being such as abdominal obesity, inflammation, and high blood pressure, all of which can lead to long-term health problems, including heart disease, stroke and cancer

The suicide cult

For many years, those in preventive medicine knew that when the press reported a suicide, that other suicides would follow> That is why they alway recommended to newspapers to minimize the story and NOT to be sympathetic to the person or to his/her action.

Well, in recent years, the pro suicide movement has been glamourizing suicide for those unhappy with life. My cynical take is that this is a forerunner to the idea that the old/handicapped/brain injured should be offed by their docs, with or without the consent of their families or themselves. And the reason behind it is not compassion but to save money.

So ScienceDaily reports on why the suicide rate of white men is so high.

Particularly pernicious for this group may be the belief that suicide is a masculine response to "the indignities of aging." This is a script that implicitly justifies, and even glorifies, suicide among men.
 As illustrations, in her article Canetto examines two famous cases. Eastman Kodak founder George Eastman died of suicide in 1932, at age 77. His biographer said Eastman was "unprepared and unwilling to face the indignities of old age." Writer Hunter S. Thompson, who killed himself in 2005 at age 67, was described by friends as having triumphed over "the indignities of aging."
Both suicides were explained in the press through scripts of conventional "white" masculinity, Canetto asserts.
"The dominant story was that their suicide was a rational, courageous, powerful choice."
 Canetto's research challenges the notion that high suicide rates are inevitable among white older men. As additional evidence that suicide in this population is culturally determined, and thus preventable, Canetto points out that older men are not the most suicide-prone group everywhere in the world. For example, in China, women of reproductive age are the demographic group with the highest suicide mortality.
 Among the implications of Canetto's research is that attention to cultural scripts of suicide offers new ways of understanding and preventing suicide. As cultural stories, the "indignities of aging" suicide script as well as the belief that suicide is a white man's powerful response to aging can and should be challenged, and changed, she says.

Wednesday, December 23, 2015

Lives matter?

BBC has a story of a "Christmas miracle", of a child who lived after her life support was turned off.

then we have the Texas man who kept them from turning off the life support for his "brain dead" son, by holding them off with a gun.

He was drunk, so ended up in jail and not shot by the SWAT team who negotiated hoping he'd sober up, but the really strange part of the story is that his son lived.

then there is the Jahi McMath case... and if you don't think minority patients will start getting suspicious, you are naive.

We had one of our nursing home patients who was alert but with frontal lobe brain damage. She couldn't swallow very well, so had a feeding tube. But frontal lobe damabe meant she cried with tears as if sad when she saw her family, and she could be quite loud. So we sent her to a neurologist to see if there was a medicine that could help her without sedating her.

The neurologist didn't examine her, but spent the whole time advising the family to remove the feeding tube.

The parents and siblings, traditional Indians, kept their silence, but on leaving, the cousin, an LPN who had accompanied her to the doc, turned and told him off saying: That's the difference between you white people and us: We care for our sick and elderly.



Wednesday, December 9, 2015

E Coli and Shigella: Fly, fingers, feces germs

Article on toxic EColi at Chipote restaurants.

If it is from fresh salads, then why not start nuking the lettuce?

 This article is from the wapo 2008:

Food producers can now use radiation to kill bacteria on fresh spinach and iceberg lettuce because of a new Food and Drug Administration ruling meant to help head off outbreaks of foodborne illness.
 This is the first time the agency has allowed produce to be irradiated as a health precaution. Tiny doses of radiation already are used to kill pests on some fruits and vegetables. But the process is most often used on meat -- especially E. coli susceptible ground beef -- and some spices.
The food is exposed to just enough radiation to kill off most, though not necessarily all, harmful germs. For instance, the process won't rid the produce of foodborne viruses.

when we sell our organic salads, we grow the lettuce etc inside greenhouses (to stop bugs) and then clean them off by putting them into a water bath with chlorox type bleach, and then washing them off and air drying them before we make the salad.

And if it is from undercooked meat, then make folks wash hands and counters, and check the meat is cooked properly. Often there is cross contamination from "fresh" meat that dripped on counters and gets onto hands or onto plates or cooked food.

_________________________

Related item:

Shigella outbreak in Texas schools and daycares.

again, local health officials are checking hand washing and washing down the place with chlorox.

But since kids are not tidy, they might be spreading it to families.

Ordinarily I would blame the failure to screen food workers for being carriers, or blame the failure of checking that hands are properly washed.

But the epidemic is in so many places one wonders if food is the source.

And pet turtles have caused epidemics in the past.

the bad news: Usually you don't treat with antibiotics since the disease clears itself and giving antibiotics only increases the chance of resistant germs

But the disease is now becoming resistant to common antibiotics.

a lot of cases are imported but then spread. CDC report here 

they also add:
Shigella causes an estimated 500,000 cases of diarrhea in the United States annually (1) and is transmitted easily from person to person and through contaminated food and recreational water. Outbreaks of shigellosis frequently are large and protracted. Although diarrhea caused by S. sonnei typically resolves without treatment, patients with mild illness often are treated with antimicrobial medications because they can reduce the duration of symptoms and shedding of shigellae in feces (2)
and

Reserving antimicrobial treatment for immunocompromised patients and patients with severe shigellosis and using antimicrobial susceptibility data strategically to guide therapy might help preserve the utility of such medications. 

an article that summarizes the treatment of diarrhea type illnesses can be found HERE. 

but with all the resistance, the use of "probiotics" and other things are being looked into.

Heh. Lactulose, the artificial sugar used to treat constipation and as a low cal sweetener, has been investigated and seems to help (but not cure) the carrier state. (but doesn't help acute cases).